Tuesday, August 18, 2009

The Govenment's Kids

History of the Global Now
Current Event Reflection
Terese Howard
8/18/09

An article in the New York times on August 17, 2009 entitled Dangling Money, Obama Pushes Education Shift discusses the Obama administrations recent proposal to send $4.3 billion to states education departments under the conditions that they uphold certain rules including using standardized tests to judge teachers. The article states “Holding out billions of dollars as a potential windfall, the Obama administration is persuading state after state to rewrite education laws to open the door to more charter schools and expand the use of student test scores for judging teachers.”
Under the law schools are required to have a direct tie between students standardized test scores and their eligibility to receive the $4.3 billion. New York Times states, “The law requires schools to bring all students to proficiency in reading and math by 2014 and penalizes those that do not meet annual goals.” Standardized tests serve the main form of judgment in order to earn the $4.3 billion.
Now, may I ask, how is learning/education commodified into data that can make a school more or less worthy of getting stimulus money? Are children the Federal government’s project to create into super stars? Should the Federal government have the right to control states via bribing them with money to get them to apply to the Federal government’s ideals? One representative of California education said that “We’ll do everything in our power, to make sure that California is in compliance with the expectations of the Obama administration.” Is this not federalizing education? Whose education is this anyway – the kids or the governments?
All quotes come from: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/17/education/17educ.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1&sq=Aug%2017%202009&st=cse&scp=10

1 comment:

Krystan said...

This looks like Bush's No Child Left Behind Act turned inside out, or liberalized, if you will. Instead of a negative approach (Bush: Everybody score well or I'll spank you [fire all your teachers and liquidate your district]), it's a positive approach (Obama: Everybody who scores high enough gets a candy [money]). I don't believe there are any real education reforms that come from the government. They come from individual parents (such as your own) or groups of parents taking advantage of our relatively permissive system and making micro-reforms as they see fit. Public school DOES belong to the government. It is one of the chief organs of government, decidedly a sibling of the military. This is why there is always so much hooplah over what teachers, as government employees, can and cannot say in the classroom. Interestingly, in some (many?) developed/more socialized countries (Netherlands and Germany, that I know of) homeschooling is not allowed. Everyone is expected to express citizenship by attending school. This is one reason to like America, anyway: here we express our citizenship by raising hell over any and every attempt to temper our autonomy.